• Welcome to The Truck Stop! We see you haven't REGISTERED yet.

    Your truck knowledge is missing!
    • Registration is FREE , all we need is your birthday and email. (We don't share ANY data with ANYONE)
    • We have tons of knowledge here for your diesel truck!
    • Post your own topics and reply to existing threads to help others out!
    • NO ADS! The site is fully functional and ad free!
    CLICK HERE TO REGISTER!

    Problems registering? Click here to contact us!

    Already registered, but need a PASSWORD RESET? CLICK HERE TO RESET YOUR PASSWORD!

Towing long and heavy with a 6.5? Read on

great white

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,007
Reaction score
109
Location
Canada's Ocean Playground
Disclaimer; Most (or all) of this will be nothing new to the "old dogs" on the board, but a newb or two might find a couple "nuggets" here that may help them along.

So you want to tow heavy and long with a 6.5?
I’m living proof that a 6.5 can take whatever North America can dish out while towing and towing heavy. From high and long mountain passes in the west, to rolling hills and oppressive heat in the foothills, to oppressive heat and high speed running in flatlands, to twisting roads in the Appalachian mountains, to high winds in the East. It can handle it all.

But not in "as delivered" form and certainly not after it has some age on it. If you think yours is “pretty new”, you better think again. The newest 6.5 (as delivered from GM) is now 10 years old…..

Having just finished towing an 8000+lb travel trailer from West coast to East coast as far as you can go either way without getting wet, allow me to share a few observations, recommendations and techniques.

You can use some or all of these things, but to get to where I ended up (and the “performance level”) you should seriously consider all of it. I will break it down into “need” and “want” which is pretty self explanatory. You can make your own decisions on that if you wish.

A word of warning, this is going to be an expensive list.

I’m not pulling any punches either. I would NEVER tow with one of these old rigs ever again without ALL of these improvements.

You may decide to just buy a newer Duramax, Powerstroke or Cummins after reading all this. Any of these vehicle options will give you a better, more capable rig right from the start. But if you like the old GMT400 chassis and want to spend way more on it that you probably should, read on.

The Truck:

As GM delivered it, it’s not a towing machine. It was made to deliver MPG and then GM “pumped up” the original design to try and compete with the offerings coming out from Dodge and Ford. They cut corners, tacked stuff on with what gives the appearance of very little R&D and the electronics are a half step measure towards full electronic control. None of this is a winning recipe for power or longevity. You can agree with that or not, your choice.

It needs some help if you intend to tow heavy or far. It can get by in stock form if it’s still healthy, but throw in anything other than a “Sunday drive” and it’s going to struggle. These trucks are also no longer “spring chickens”, so yours is probably pretty tired if you haven’t already entered the “rebuild/replace” cycle.

So, in MY order of importance (yours may differ), the list….

Engine-

Class ; depends

This is going to be a bitter pill to swallow, very expensive and not a popular reccomendation but replace it if there is any doubt to its condition.

Don’t go any less than a New 6500 Optimizer or a P400. Anything less is just a waste of time and money.

Don’t rebuild one, don’t buy a rebuilt one, they’re both a waste of time and money.

Assuming you can find a good block, it’s on borrowed time and will crack, leak or just plain old give out on you. Get some new iron, don’t waste your time on a design that was flawed and overstressed from the get go. You get a redesigned block and heads, fresh pistons and rings, as just an all around better lump.

Expect to spend at least around 7,000. Like I said, a bitter pill but you’ll have a solid base to build on that will handle the load for the next 300,000 kms without cracking mains, splitting heads or shattering crankshafts. It also wil put a complete end to any leaks you’re pulling your hair out chasing down.

You may get away with a military “take out” surplus unit (it should also be a GEP unit), but you’re taking your chances there. Many have reported good experiences so far. But it’s very much “Buyer Beware”….

I’ve been sitting by the side of the highway with a holed piston, an 8000 lb trailer, the family in the vehicle and semi’s whipping by. You absolutely NEED a solid base if you plan to trust your family’s well being to the vehicle, the Optimizer or P400 is it. GM’s original iron (or a “Chinese” block and heads) is not.

Injectors

Class: Need

These are a CRITICALitem. A bad set will kill your pistons in very short order. Even a brand new optimizer or P400 longblock.

If your injectors have any more than 100,000 miles on them with a basic daily driver, replace them. Don’t go for rebuilts, just order up some new BOSCH ones from a reputable dealer. I used Heath, but any reputable dealer will do as long as they’re NEW BOSCH units.

I originally ordered a NOS set from eBay. While they were good in just daily driving, once I started hammering on them with serious towing they deteriorated rapidly.
If you’ve got considerable towing miles on your injectors, chop about 20-30,000 off that 100,000 interval.

That’s not my recommendation; I got it from "someone" very knowledgeable about the whole issue.

Injectors are the silent killer for a 6.5……don’t cheap out, replace them often. Expect to spend around 600 bucks.

The Turbo

Class; Need

A healthy GM8 gets it done. At least, it did on mine. But it needs to be healthy. A previous model GMX is probably fine also, as long as it’s in solid shape. An “A Team Turbo” (Mitsubishi unit) may work better, but I believe it is an optional upgrade and it can wait until your healthy stock GMx is no longer “healthy”.

Expect around 7-800 bucks for an ATT or a bit more for a replacement GMx.

Guages

Class: Need

EGT’s - You absolutely MUST have an EGT guage (also called pyrometer). Brand doesn’t matter, but it must be good quality.

Boost - A boost guage is essential only if you add a turbo master. You need it to adjust the spring for maximum boost. Too much and you can be popping head gaskets, too little and you get black smoke and high EGT’s.

Expect to spend anywhere from a couple hunny to 500.

Class ; Want
Fuel pressure- for the lift pump. Loose the lift pump and bad things can start happening to power and the life of your injection pump.

Transmission temperature – you can get by without one, but you should have one. Heat kills transmissions.

Axle temp – good for seeing your temps, but the 14 bolt corporate GM unit is one strong diff. The G80 RPO code “gov lock” is a different story…

Transfer case temp- Good if you have a 4x4 and tow. GM transfer cases tend to run hot in normal driving, towing is worse. Change the oil regularly.

PMD

Class: Need

Don’t we all love this little piece of Kit! (sarcasm)

If you’ve ever experienced a failing PMD, you know what I’m talking about.

If you don’t know how old it is, get a spare. Get one now! Have it on a heat sink and ready to go.

If it is failing, get a new one on an extender and get it completely out of the engine bay. 3 things kill electronics; heat, vibration and voltage spikes. These buggers run hot, get it somewhere where it can shed that heat quickly. That means a good supply of moving, cool air.

Not trying to sound like a Heath diesel commercial, but his prices are highly competitive on these and he offers a 7 year warranty….hard to beat that anywhere…..

Expect to spend anywhere from 500-1000 smackers a pop for new.

Lift Pump


Class: need

How old is it? Don’t know? Better at least have a spare in the glove box. Bad things will happen if it goes out towing. Best case is reduced power and added strain on the Injection pump. Worst case scenario, it could cost you an injection pump…

Fuel filter

Class; need

Just keep up with regular maintenance.

Turbo Master

Class; depends.

Keeps the boost on while towing which keeps the fuel rate up. GM designed the stock program to pull back boost whenever it can to save MPG. Great on a truck built for MPG, bad for one that is towing. When the boost comes back, so does the fuel, then the power follows right behind that and then that big 9x8 foot 8000 lb sail behind you pulls the speed down. Now you have to “get it into it” to speed up and then the PCM pulls everything back again, and you have to get into it, and…..well, you get the idea. But you can get it done with the stock vacuum wastegate system. It’s just not as good at it unless you have the program “altered”.

You can cobble something up with threaded rod and some nuts for around 10 bucks or you can buy a readymade unit from Heath for around 120 bucks.

Your choice, I went with the Heath unit and have absolutely no regrets. Money well spent.

Note: If you go with a Heath PCM (discussed later) you should buy a turbo master. In my experience, it doesn’t play well with the stock vacuum system as it is programmed for the particular operation of a turbo master unit.

Exhaust

Class; need.

Get yourself a minimum mandrel bent turbo back 3 inch system and a 2.5” crossover pipe. The most popular these days are a 3” downpipe (largest that physically fits) and then a 4 inch back from that. Same price usually, so go for the 4 inch system. Mine is the 2.5” warpspeed crossover and a 4” turbo back Diamond eye with a stainless muffler.

Radiator

Class; Need

Your rad must be sound and clean. Inside and out. If you don’t know how old it is, pull it out and send it to a rad shop for testing and cleaning. They will clean the core inside and out. It will assure you get all the cooling it is capable of. The 6.5 produces a lot of heat due to it’s IDI design. You need a solid rad to support it.

Clean out the oil coolers and AC evap core while you’re got it apart. Get a “rad comb” and straighten what fins you can to help ease restrictions in front of the rad also.

Water Pump

Class; Need

Have a 98+ model year water pump in there. If it is and you don’t know how old it is, better think about replacing it. These pumps go forever and then fail all at once. they are good one day and are pouring coolant out the weep hole the next.

This is another key link in keeping that hard working IDI cool.

While you’re at it, replace the hoses also. Popped hose on an interstate/highway can really ruin your day. In the big picture, hoses are cheap, so are belts. Both are really maintenance items anyways.

Fan and Clutch

Class; need

You want a 9 blade steel fan and a solid working clutch as a minimum.

I’m running the stock 98 clutch and 9 blade steel fan and it gets the job done just fine. But it's all heathy and in good shape. years and wear may dictate you need to change the cltuch out.

Many have switched up to a Duramax fan and a SD clutch. Your choice, but it must be in top shape no matter what you choose.

Thermostats

Class; Need

Get a good set (or a single if you truck is not dual stats) of AC Delco 195 units. If you have no idea if they’re older than a year or two, replace ‘em. They’re cheap to buy and are really another maintenance item.

You can go with 180 units if you prefer, but I have had excellent cooling performance with a new set of 190 AC Delcos and I won’t have to deal with poor mileage unloaded or heater performance issues in winter. Your choice….

PCM

Class: I’m going to say need, but it could be want

If you’re going to tow, in hills or flats, I can’t recommend a modified program enough. I’ve run both a stock PCM, my own tuned PCM (not optimized for towing though) and a Heath PCm in hilly and windy conditions. To be blunt, the stock can get it done, but flat out sucks when compared to the Heath PCM. That’s for flat and uphill towing though. There’s no comparison between the stocker and the Heath PCM in the downhill portions.

If you tow in hills, you need a Heath PCM with his hill assist feature. I’ll say it again since it’s soooo good; If you tow in hills, you NEED a heath PCM with hill assist feature.

Engine and transmission Mounts


Class; need

If your mounts are deteriorated, replace ‘em. Trans mount is most subject to deterioration due to the heat and oil spatter it usually lives in.
‘Nuff said.

Fluidampr

Class; want

Seriously, if you put in a new optimizer, it’s going to come with a new stock damper. But the difference in “smoothness” and longevity between the stock damper and the fluidampr needs to be experienced to be understood. Plus, you don’t have to worry about the rubber coming apart and shattering your new crank. Call it 400 dollars of insurance for your 7000 dollar long block…..

Water Injection

Class; want

Look very closely at the words I chose; WATER injection, not Water METH injection. Water ONLY for a 6.5....

To tell the truth, with all the improvements listed above, my new optimizer 6500 almost doesn’t seem to care if the water is one or off, egt’s are pretty close to the same. It does seem to help keeping the coolant temps down.

It goes without saying the rest of the truck must be sound. IE: front end suspension and steering components, proper towing gear (Weight distribution hitch, etc), transmission, axles, bearings, electronics, etc.

You must also keep up with the maintenance items such as engine oil, trans oil, gear lube, etc….

With this combination, I towed from Ellensburg WA to Gander Newfoundland and finished with a truck showing 420,000+ km’s on the clock. Prior to that, I used the thrashed 599 block to tow it (almost to Ellensburg. It pulled equally well with everything you see below the optimizer recommendatioin, until it stove in a piston from just plain old age.

That’s 6471 kms or 3806 miles in one shot. 6983 kms (4107 miles) from start to finish.

It conquered 4th of july pass, vantage highway, lookout pass, the hills around Butte, the horrible hills heat and winds of Wyoming, the oppressive heat and humidly (34+ degrees before the humidex) of the plains, fast interstate running in the east, the Appalachians, high winds and hills it in the Maritimes and climbing and twisting through beautiful scenic Newfoundland. Once the PMD issues were sorted, it pulled our 8000+lb travel trailer with relative ease and power. Even before the PMD problems were sorted, it pulled the combo with confidence. Passing vehicles at and above the speed limit was not only possible, it was a fact. It could easily haul the combo up to 80+mph (scary on trailer tires!), even though I ran around 60-65 mph almost everywhere.

That brings us to the last (and maybe most important) category:

Driving

Class; need

This is a pretty gray area and almost an art more than a science. You just have to get out there and build up some experience.

My general recommendation for a 6.5 is this; Watch the EGT’s, watch the Coolant temps and what the fuel gauge. The speedometer is basically to keep you from getting tickets. If you’re moving slower than traffic or the speed limit, so be it. They may be pissed off moving slow behind you, but they’ll be even more pissed off if you break it and block the road. Not to mention, your wallet will be getting really light after blowing the engine…

Keep the coolant below 210, let off throttle and slow down if you have to. That goes for hills or flats. If you’re built it right though, it shouldn’t be much of an issue anyways. Spike 215 if you must, but only for shot intervals then slow down and cool it off.

Preferably, keep the EGT’s below 1000, don’t sustain much more than 1050. Spike 1100 if you have to, but get it out of there ASAP. Exceed 1100 at your own peril. Most hills I would set 980 on the EGT gauge and climb the hill at that EGT, maybe spiking up to 1050 if needed. This would get me 55 mph on 4th of July pass and 45-50 on Lookout Pass. Flat running I could almost ignore the EGT’s and watch the speedo, coolant and fuel.

Downshift to third before you speed gets up on the down hills. Again, the Heath program let me descend most hills without down shifting and no ( or minimal) brake applications. It’s just that good…

These are my recommendations for a solid, reliable travel trailer pulling GMT 400 6.5 Turbo diesel.

Your mileage may vary…

;)
 
In context if you want as trouble free trip as possible, go with the newest and low mile truck you can. May not be trouble free, but the odds over old worn out technology are better.

The above advice is good. However one point is unpopular because it is overkill in these old trucks.
"Don’t go any less than a New 6500 Optimizer or a P400. Anything less is just a waste of time and money. "

This simply doesn't make any economic sense. These old trucks need enough other parts to push them to their blue book value as it is. Some trucks do not need an engine swap already having a good 6.5 in them! Those of us buying an old truck like this have a small budget. A used military 6.2 engine, I could buy 6 of them for $7500, will get the job done. The Optimizer is for Hummers or Suburbans where replacements that are diesel powered are not available. $7500 could also buy you a tanker of gasoline for a 454 or 8.1L gasser. If you are restoring a vehicle and money is not an object go for it. For the rest of us getting what we can out of old iron...

The best thing to do form a cost standpoint is to swap the high blowby 6.5 for a military surplus 6.2. This makes the decision to actually swap the worn high blowby engine out easier as the cost is lower.
As blogged and is well known and engine with high blowby has worn rings or other wear problems for a cause. This means other parts of the engine are worn as well like copper showing in bearings about to spin and lockup. Two things to do during a surplus engine swap is to use ARP head studs and re-ring the engine. (Re-ring is not necessary, but, I have learned that is will do better in the long run and ebay rings are cheap.) The ~$600.00 set of gapless rings will keep your oil clean and is a want if you have the extra for them.

An engine swap with almost no budget cost me $2000.00 with a new Powermaster starter and ARP head studs. Vibration damper and engine mounts are some odds and ends of a swap. With $7500 I simply would have purchased a 1996 or newer Dodge Diesel pickup.

I have towed hard and heavy with the ~1986 6.2's dropped in my 1993 with the turbo. 10% grades and foot on the floor 550 miles a day with 1/3 turn more fuel and boost at the turbo limit of 14 PSI. I have 30,000 miles towing on a surplus 6.2 repower and counting.
You have 30,000 miles before the main cracks start. This is 60,000 miles on the engine since new. Until the main cracks actually cause failure is higher millage. (I pulled the engine down after I put 30K on it.) The advantage to a low mile military engine is that the cracks have not started yet.

3 weeks after the engine swap I hit an elk. Bluebook value is important here. The $7500.00 engine on a $4000.00 truck, do you even have full coverage on a truck like this? Stolen or burned to the ground - you will not get your engine back.

In summery there are other engine choices out there that will get you a long way down the road. Especially if you are on a tight budget. Sure the Optimizer is the best 6.5 engine out there, but, we are not working with the best tow rig out there. (I have the parts bill to prove it.) Getting passed on hills by other tow rigs makes a orange triangle standard equipment for a 6.5 and further makes my point.
 
In context if you want as trouble free trip as possible, go with the newest and low mile truck you can. May not be trouble free, but the odds over old worn out technology are better.

The above advice is good. However one point is unpopular because it is overkill in these old trucks.
"Don’t go any less than a New 6500 Optimizer or a P400. Anything less is just a waste of time and money. "

This simply doesn't make any economic sense. These old trucks need enough other parts to push them to their blue book value as it is. Some trucks do not need an engine swap already having a good 6.5 in them! Those of us buying an old truck like this have a small budget. A used military 6.2 engine, I could buy 6 of them for $7500, will get the job done. The Optimizer is for Hummers or Suburbans where replacements that are diesel powered are not available. $7500 could also buy you a tanker of gasoline for a 454 or 8.1L gasser. If you are restoring a vehicle and money is not an object go for it. For the rest of us getting what we can out of old iron...

The best thing to do form a cost standpoint is to swap the high blowby 6.5 for a military surplus 6.2. This makes the decision to actually swap the worn high blowby engine out easier as the cost is lower.
As blogged and is well known and engine with high blowby has worn rings or other wear problems for a cause. This means other parts of the engine are worn as well like copper showing in bearings about to spin and lockup. Two things to do during a surplus engine swap is to use ARP head studs and re-ring the engine. (Re-ring is not necessary, but, I have learned that is will do better in the long run and ebay rings are cheap.) The ~$600.00 set of gapless rings will keep your oil clean and is a want if you have the extra for them.

An engine swap with almost no budget cost me $2000.00 with a new Powermaster starter and ARP head studs. Vibration damper and engine mounts are some odds and ends of a swap. With $7500 I simply would have purchased a 1996 or newer Dodge Diesel pickup.

I have towed hard and heavy with the ~1986 6.2's dropped in my 1993 with the turbo. 10% grades and foot on the floor 550 miles a day with 1/3 turn more fuel and boost at the turbo limit of 14 PSI. I have 30,000 miles towing on a surplus 6.2 repower and counting.
You have 30,000 miles before the main cracks start. This is 60,000 miles on the engine since new. Until the main cracks actually cause failure is higher millage. (I pulled the engine down after I put 30K on it.) The advantage to a low mile military engine is that the cracks have not started yet.

3 weeks after the engine swap I hit an elk. Bluebook value is important here. The $7500.00 engine on a $4000.00 truck, do you even have full coverage on a truck like this? Stolen or burned to the ground - you will not get your engine back.

In summery there are other engine choices out there that will get you a long way down the road. Especially if you are on a tight budget. Sure the Optimizer is the best 6.5 engine out there, but, we are not working with the best tow rig out there. (I have the parts bill to prove it.)

I'm gonna guess you missied my comments about the surplus take out you can get.

Also the statement about just buying a newer/different diesel.

I'm ignoring trade, bluebook etc. If that mattered, you wouldn't be working on one of these anyways.

We all know these old hacks are money pits and you will never get you money back out of it.

heck, you'll never get you money out of anything with 4 wheels, unless you're talking collector cars or the proverbial "screamin' deal"....
 
downhill decent feature. I allready have that with the factory programming! :)

Ill be the a-hole to say it. It is best to start with a 5 speed if you want to make a 6.5L tow on as little $ as possible. there is no huge need for an aftermarket ECM or chip for downhill control, as you are already locked up with the clutch. just let off the pedal,and let it roll. stays cooler with no trans cooler in the equation, so may get by with an HO pump rather than getting a balanced pump, or 9 blade rather than duramax fan, and more power to the ground, so it may meet some folks power requirements enough to eliminate the need for a chip/ECM

good writeup BJ, your one sentence sums up my thoughts of towing with a 6.5L. "If you’re moving slower than traffic or the speed limit, so be it. They may be pissed off moving slow behind you, but they’ll be even more pissed off if you break it and block the road."

I just dont see the economic benefit to pulling a hill at 70 mph. it takes a lot of money and parts to get there. slower is cheaper. the major fleets in the US seem to share the thought of slower is cheaper, so I will watch you blow my doors off while I am in the slow lane with the flashers on with the fleet trucks.
 
Thank you both for sharing.

My grocery getter has 220K on it. It's 2wd & 1/2 ton & prolly worth $3K tops. I think I am gonna keep it until it blows & then be forced to make a difficult decision. I really like my trucks looks & ride quality & interior layout. Wish it had a 3rd door but what ever. Being as though mine is a 1/2 ton I am prone to believe it's lived a fairly easy life. I bought it from a repair shop that purchased it from the original owner. It had cosmetic damage from a front end collision, that's why it has a 92 front end on it. Mine is starting to show cancer on the door bottoms & some areas that appear to have been repaired on the cab corners once already. I really hate RUST.

I have a hard time just driving things into the ground, but I really need to consider how much money I want to pour into this 1995...one very very positive thing is it's paid for.
 
No, I just respectfully disagree with the conclusion with the reasons given.

Ignoring bluebook, well, your insurance company needs to be in tune with this by declared value or you have to be willing to write it off. I came too close to a total write off myself to not mention this risk and heartbreak.

I have already obtained a different truck. As much as I like the 6.5 and a pink slip, the parts needed and MPG under load vs. other trucks make it uncompetitive. Aka the difference between a profit and loss. DOT hours of service limits are an additional issue/consideration when you are doing 43 MPH on long hills vs. 65 MPH. (I can burn a lot of extra fuel for a hotel stay cost w/ meals.)
 
The 6.5 is just not a good "daily" tow rig unless you do what BJ said and maybe a stick like GM guy said.
These 6.5s are light duty diesels.
Another option is to put a 12 valve Cummins in. It will just about fall into place on its own in a 2wd. Even a 4bt might be better and when unloaded can get 30ish mpg.
But, for everyday driving the 6.5 is great, gets good mpg's and is cheap to work on compaired to other diesels.
 
excatly, I'm sorry but spending 7000+$ for an engine on a 90's truck is pure nuts. I would never spend more than 1500$ putting an engine in anyone of my toilets. I tow. In fact I have towed with 6.5s alot more and for more years. You did one trip. I'd do a Cummins swap if anything. You got a crap set of squirts from a hack on eBay and it burned up your motor. I towed my camper all over the place with my Tahoe and it had 185k miles on it. I am sorry you had such bad luck on your trip but to imply that the only real option is to spend 7k+ putting a new engine if one wants to tow is misleading. I also disagree about the Heath tune or TM. I am running neither on my Suburban and to date it tows the coolest of all the 6.5's I have owned. proved it today. It's a bit of a dog but the vacuum system does more than MPG, it keeps the engine within safe parameters of boost and fuel. Once you "tune" it and override the wastegate, you put the engine in dangerous territory. Past what it was designed to do. My 6.5 does what I need and drags my camper around a few times a year not too far from home. If I was gonna do alot of towing or major distances, I would not use a 6.5 I had a Cummins but I sold it because a 250$ a month payment wasn't worth it for something I basically "needed" 3-4x a year. Sorry to be blunt but that is my opinion.
I do agree with you about rebuilding these engines. IMHO they are just like 3208 cats, when their dead, their dead. They were meant to be throw aways. The only real way to rebuild it is start with a new block and then what are you actually rebuilding ?? Look at Robyns Dually. She knows her shit. She rebuilt hers and the thing let go.If it can happen to a pro like her, then it can happen to anyone. Truth is you cannot tell the stress on the block even with testing. Like WW said, a used motor with a frshen up might not be so bad but that's about it. Once you start machining an already weak block...well I wouldn't.
 
Last edited:
downhill decent feature. I allready have that with the factory programming! :)

there is no huge need for an aftermarket ECM or chip for downhill control,.

If all you are looking for is downhiill decent control, in other words keeping the converter locked..... you do not need an aftermarket ECM anyway. You can make it happen with the bone stock ECM and PROM. Ask me how I know.

Two pieces of wire and a switch accomplishes the same thing. How much does two pieces of wire and a toggle switch cost?


excatly, I'm sorry but spending 7000+$ for an engine on a 90's truck is pure nuts. I would never spend more than 1500$ putting an engine in anyone of my toilets. I'd do a Cummins swap if anything. You got a crap set of squirts from a hack on eBay and it burned up your motor. I am sorry you had such bad luck on your trip but to imply that the only real option is to spend 7k+ putting a new engine is is misleading.

I know what GW said in his original post about "the only way to go", I disagree too. A military take out in good condition will, in my opinion, last just as long as a brand new $7,000 GM dealer 6.5..... Provided they are both cared for the same.

However, I am getting tired of seeing BJ getting his balls busted for his decision and basically told "you are retarded for paying $7,000 for a new 6.5."

I think you all are forgetting the situation or the choices that BJ had at the moment his old 6.5 let go.

Put yourself in his shoes for a moment....You're on the side of the road stranded in Washington state, a camper in tow packed with a lot of your stuff, and the wife in a car behind you. You have no "home" to tow it to.... You have no friends to call..... You have a week or so left to get all the way across the country with the camper and your stuff, no choice on that one at all.

He had basically 3 choices as I see it....

1) Leave the chevy on the side of the road (with all the mods, upgrades, and time you have invested) and go buy a brand new truck (30K and up)....or buy a used truck, but what kind of problems does the used truck have? What's worn out or ready to break on it? Would you head across country towing a huge camper in a "brand new to you" used truck as soon as you drive it off the lot? How much would a used truck, that you felt comfortable towing a huge camper from coast to coast with, cost you.... 15K - 20K.... more? Also, remember, you only have a couple days to find one that suits your needs, meets your "price range", and seems "comforatbly reliable" before you have to hook up the camper again and hit the road.

2) Hurry up and find a "used" replacement 6.2 or 6.5 to put in his truck. Where are you gonna get one in Washington state with only a day or so to find a "good one"? Remember you gotta give the shop a few days to swap engines for you.... What kind of shape will that used engine be in? Do you trust it to make it all the way from coast to coast without leaving you on the side of the road again?

3) Get a "new" 6.5 for the truck. Now, with only having a few days to work with, where are you going to get a new 6.5? One with a warranty, one that you know has 0 miles on it, one that you know doesn't have cracked mains or blown head gaskets, one that will get you to the other side of the continent without leaving you on the side of the road again....that's right, at the dealer. Stuff at the dealer is expensive.....we all know that.... but where else are you going to get it?

It sucks, I agree, but again..... You have to look at the big picture and the entire situation at hand before saying "you're pure nuts for spending $7,000+ for an engine". What would you have done?

Cummins swap....not even an option in this senerio. No time to find a good 12V and accomplish all the fab work, modifications, etc. Plus there is always a few "bugs" to work out once you get it running and driving for a little while. BJ did not have time, tools, patience, or the want to work out more "bugs" along the road from coast to coast.

Taking the entire situation into account.....I, for one, stand beside BJ and his decision to get a brand new 6.5 to fix his truck. All other options at that point are either more expensive or less reliable than a new 6.5.

Break downs on the side of the road are expensive, especially when you are THAT far from home.... He tried to limit his time sitting somewhere with major mechanical failures to just one for the entire trip.... I don't blame him at all.

Now..... let the bullets start flying....
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the write up BJ!

Yup he was definitely in a position that left him very few choices. I just wish that he would have had better luck, really sucks the big one.

But hey he ends up with a practically new truck now with the demonstrated proven ability to pull his trailer & prolly most anything he wants to hook to it.

No matter how much we try or how much we prepare for something we can't always predict the outcome.

He made the only choice he could & went above & beyond what most men would have been able to endure.

My hat is off to you BJ you did good & I will go out on a limb & suggest the majority of members (prolly ALL) here feel the same...:tiphat
 
BJ great write up, I am sure that took you quite a long time to write and even longer to live it. My hats off to you! :tiphat

We can all nay say the original posters thread all we want. But when the shit hits the fan and we are stuck on the side of the freeway 100's of miles from home with our entire family only god knows what we will do before we do.

Give the guy a break, he just stole a 6.5TD right out of the devils hands. A hell of a lot more than I would have done! :thumbsup:
 
This thread is about advice given in the 1st post. I also agreed with BJ's decision to get a new 6.5 due to his situation and posted so in the other thread. I enjoyed his other thread and I am glad he shared his trip. The other good advice BJ has including the injector advice I not only agree with, but, have walked in his shoes.
 
I would never spend more than 1500$ putting an engine in anyone of my toilets.

Ace I have read many off your posts and can see that you a mechanic at heart.

But to say $1500 for a engine replacement is way off. Machine shop alone can be that and plus just for basic work. just got a LS block back from machine on thursday and the block alone was $1200 and the heads were over $500. thats basic work done; we do all our own balance ($300) our own bowl and dress the valves ($400) and depending on how deep you want to get with the ports thats a lot more also ( $300-$600). now lets not forget gaskets, bearings and a whole grocery list of small parts to boot.

so the $7K the GW spent is not that far from actual real world costs of a nicely built, dependable engine thats gonna last for quite some time.

actually he pretty much get one hell of a good deal on it. and good for him.
 
It's got nothing do do with "his situation". he posted a new thread implying that spending 7000$ is what someone needs to do if they want to tow. Now if the thread started I was on the side of the road broke down and had to spend 7K that's different but he posted an advice thread on building a truck to tow and I disagree with the need to spend 7000$ on a 15 yr old truck to do that so if some don't like that then by all means ban me. it seems this forum has lost alot of what it used to be IMHO. I was here from the start of it and over at DP long before some of the newbs came along so if that is the way things are tilted..I"LL move on but I was under the impression that is was an open forum and if you post something, you get others input, otherwise either don't post, have it locked or friggin ban me. I am truly sorry for all the bad luck he had but those were not his ONLY options. He could have rented a ryder truck. he could have had the camper and truck transported to it's destination for alot less than he spent me thinks but he had a thread on that already and other than me voicing my opinion (when he asked for opinions before he made the choice)I said no more about that. Again different thread, he did what he thought best , so be it.. I was not the only one. . This is a thread IMHO where he is trying to re justify to the world that one MUST spend for a NEW Optimizer or don't tow...How many 6.5's have you owned and towed with ?? Betcha I have owned and towed with more...I know in his shoes, I would not spend 10k but then again I would never in a million years even attempt a trip like that with a 6.5td especially under time constraints.
The OP emphasized a new motor is the way to go. I wholeheartedly disagree so ban me.
 
Last edited:
Ace I have read many off your posts and can see that you a mechanic at heart.

But to say $1500 for a engine replacement is way off. Machine shop alone can be that and plus just for basic work. just got a LS block back from machine on thursday and the block alone was $1200 and the heads were over $500. thats basic work done; we do all our own balance ($300) our own bowl and dress the valves ($400) and depending on how deep you want to get with the ports thats a lot more also ( $300-$600). now lets not forget gaskets, bearings and a whole grocery list of small parts to boot.

so the $7K the GW spent is not that far from actual real world costs of a nicely built, dependable engine thats gonna last for quite some time.

actually he pretty much get one hell of a good deal on it. and good for him.
I never said rebuilt. I already posted I don't believe these motors were meant to be rebuilt. I meant used. That is the going rate for a used 6.5 The one in my 93 cost 1,000$ and I dumped another 3-400$ in gaskets and studs and it runs mint and I am still not into the truck for more than the resale value of it.
 
Last edited:
I know what GW said in his original post about "the only way to go", I disagree too. A military take out in good condition will, in my opinion, last just as long as a brand new $7,000 GM dealer 6.5..... Provided they are both cared for the same.

However, I am getting tired of seeing BJ getting his balls busted for his decision and basically told "you are retarded for paying $7,000 for a new 6.5."

I think you all are forgetting the situation or the choices that BJ had at the moment his old 6.5 let go.

Put yourself in his shoes for a moment....You're on the side of the road stranded in Washington state, a camper in tow packed with a lot of your stuff, and the wife in a car behind you. You have no "home" to tow it to.... You have no friends to call..... You have a week or so left to get all the way across the country with the camper and your stuff, no choice on that one at all.

He had basically 3 choices as I see it....

1) Leave the chevy on the side of the road (with all the mods, upgrades, and time you have invested) and go buy a brand new truck (30K and up)....or buy a used truck, but what kind of problems does the used truck have? What's worn out or ready to break on it? Would you head across country towing a huge camper in a "brand new to you" used truck as soon as you drive it off the lot? How much would a used truck, that you felt comfortable towing a huge camper from coast to coast with, cost you.... 15K - 20K.... more? Also, remember, you only have a couple days to find one that suits your needs, meets your "price range", and seems "comforatbly reliable" before you have to hook up the camper again and hit the road.

2) Hurry up and find a "used" replacement 6.2 or 6.5 to put in his truck. Where are you gonna get one in Washington state with only a day or so to find a "good one"? Remember you gotta give the shop a few days to swap engines for you.... What kind of shape will that used engine be in? Do you trust it to make it all the way from coast to coast without leaving you on the side of the road again?

3) Get a "new" 6.5 for the truck. Now, with only having a few days to work with, where are you going to get a new 6.5? One with a warranty, one that you know has 0 miles on it, one that you know doesn't have cracked mains or blown head gaskets, one that will get you to the other side of the continent without leaving you on the side of the road again....that's right, at the dealer. Stuff at the dealer is expensive.....we all know that.... but where else are you going to get it?

It sucks, I agree, but again..... You have to look at the big picture and the entire situation at hand before saying "you're pure nuts for spending $7,000+ for an engine". What would you have done?

Cummins swap....not even an option in this senerio. No time to find a good 12V and accomplish all the fab work, modifications, etc. Plus there is always a few "bugs" to work out once you get it running and driving for a little while. BJ did not have time, tools, patience, or the want to work out more "bugs" along the road from coast to coast.

Taking the entire situation into account.....I, for one, stand beside BJ and his decision to get a brand new 6.5 to fix his truck. All other options at that point are either more expensive or less reliable than a new 6.5.

Break downs on the side of the road are expensive, especially when you are THAT far from home.... He tried to limit his time sitting somewhere with major mechanical failures to just one for the entire trip.... I don't blame him at all.

Now..... let the bullets start flying....

Already covered in his roadtrip thread, this is a thread HE POSTED about what one NEEDS or SHOULD have to tow, and I disagree.
 
Back
Top