Your thoughts may be different, but this is how I think. Wouldn't it be cheaper to just rebuild your 4500, than to buy a new one? This IS my first diesel, and my first "big" truck, but the way I think, for the cost of a new 4500, I could probably do a complete rebuild of my old one, maybe incorporate a couple of improvements (if there are any), change the clutch/pp/brg while I am in there...
I know that right now, my clutch/transmission has an issue. I think there might be a synchro issue, since I have to play with the gears to get it into 2nd, while upshifting, etc. I actually think it is more of a clutch issue though, since when I put it in gear, it wants to creep on me, and 2-3, 3-4, and 4-5 shifts are sometimes a little more effort than they should be. The clutch does not slip, so I am thinking maybe a problem with the PP... maybe a problem on one side, causing it to not operate properly. If I have to pull the tranny, I will do everything I can find that needs to be done while it is out, because there will never be a better time to do those things.
Speaking of trannies, what lube is in the NV4500, and would a synthetic alternative be effective?