• Welcome to The Truck Stop! We see you haven't REGISTERED yet.

    Your truck knowledge is missing!
    • Registration is FREE , all we need is your birthday and email. (We don't share ANY data with ANYONE)
    • We have tons of knowledge here for your diesel truck!
    • Post your own topics and reply to existing threads to help others out!
    • NO ADS! The site is fully functional and ad free!
    CLICK HERE TO REGISTER!

    Problems registering? Click here to contact us!

    Already registered, but need a PASSWORD RESET? CLICK HERE TO RESET YOUR PASSWORD!

One whine, two questions

as was explained to me to use multi discs in the same space requires thinner clutch and mat which don't seem to last as long
Got it! Interesting though, you'd think that a series of thinner clutches would do a better job. That's the idea behind motorcycle clutches (multi disk clutch packs) and our own auto trans. Considering that I'm looking at high quality OEM replacements, I think the multi disk thing might not be much of an issue. I'll make it a point to ask each vendor, just in case. Thanks for the 'heads up'!
 
I really appreciate all the info that is coming with this thread. I have never understood the torque convertor, especially the stall speed. With all the info and links in this thread I think things are finally sinking into this thick old head. I'm going to have to go back and re-read some of the stuff in here just to make sure the info is actually finding it's way into the vacuum between my ears.

Don
 
Stall speed is the rpm point at which the little stator quits doing it fluid redirect act. Any time you're accelerating or needing power, the stator lags behind, redirecting the fluid against the turbine a second time (torque multiplication). As the need for power drops off (top of the hill, cruise, etc), it catches up with the turbine and effectively 'stalls' in relation to turbine speed. At this point torque multiplication stops. Stall speed is basically the rpm point at which the magic stops inside the torque converter. You're back to 1:1 torque multiplication. 10 pounds of sugar out of a 10 pound bag.

Stall speed is all about torque multiplication. It has nothing to do with when a vehicle starts moving forward. This relies on the fin configuration inside the turbine and pump. Example, once warmed up, my truck will move forward at 5mph with the engine idling at 650rpm. The stall speed is actually around twice that rpm.

Here's a quick 'n dirty test to determine stall speed for your specific power train:

1. Bring the engine and tranny up to operating temps.
2. Lock the brakes. Set the parking brake, place wheel chocks, chain it down, etc. Whatever you need to do
to make sure that sucker will not move.

3. Place the trans in Drive.
4. Hold the brakes down and floor the accelerator pedal.
5. The engine will accelerate to a certain rpm and hold there. That's your stall speed.

WARNING: DO NOT RUN THIS TEST FOR MORE THAN 15 SECONDS ! !

Because you're really stirring up the fluid in the torque converter, it generates a LOT of heat. 15 seconds gives you a chance to take an accurate reading and stop well before the fluid gets hot. If you want/need to retest, let the engine idle in park for several minutes before retesting.

Rule of thumb:
Higher than normal RPM: weak torque converter (or modified engine)
Lower than normal RPM: weak engine

Can somebody explain in simple terms (for this simple mind) how the locking function in the TC works along with this acceleration and stall speed scenario?

Don
 
The phenomenom Dave is describing only happens for a short time. The lock up locks the engine directly to the trans and lowers the engine rpm effectively giving you another gear
 
I understand that the lockup basically locks things together like a manual tranny, not allowing any slip. So then, under acceleration/heavy pull the stator is spinning at a different speed than the turbine and until they match speed the lockup can't function. The lockup can only happen when the turbine and stator are at equal speed. Am I close,correct, or way off?

Don
 
under normal acceleration my rpms drop 4-500 rpm when it locks, so I wouldn't think it would have to be at the same speed
 
I understand that the lockup basically locks things together like a manual tranny, not allowing any slip. So then, under acceleration/heavy pull the stator is spinning at a different speed than the turbine and until they match speed the lockup can't function. The lockup can only happen when the turbine and stator are at equal speed. Am I close,correct, or way off?
Don
Pretty close. Keep in mind, you're talking about two different things. The stator is all about torque multiplication and is strictly a mechanical device. Any time the two halves of the torque converter are spinning at different speeds, the stator is doing its redirection magic to increase the torque available to the trans input shaft. The TC clutch is all about torque application. When it engages, all slippage stops. Since there's no longer any difference in rotating speeds between the two TC halves, the stator no longer functions. (So you're right: both are spinning at the same speed.) The control module decides when to do this based on multiple sensor inputs (vehicle speed, boost pressure, engine rpm, clutch input shaft rpm, etc). Typically, with the engine at operating temp and above approx 40mph, the ECM/TCM/PCM will engage the TC clutch when it senses that engine rpm is matching trans input shaft rpm.
 
Thanks Dave!!

I think I'm finally beginning to understand some of this. It sure would be easier if I had a working cut-out in front of me as I'm a visual type of learner. This thread has been great for me.

Now I need a way to put this new info to use so it won't go on through and leak out through the holes in the other side of my head. I guess I'm going to have to re-read and re-read all this to see if I can make it stick.

Thanks everybody!!! Keep the info rolling, I want more!!!



Don
 
I think with the 3.42 gears a lower stall torque converter would be nice, since I am always cruising around at like 1500rpm in OD.

Great thread I also agree. Really makes me want to switch to synthetic Tranny fluid now.

Buddy, what difference would lowering the stall speed give to you if you are always cruising around 1500rpm OD?
I thought I had everything understood until you wrote this, and now I dont' understand what effect that will have once your already cruising.
 
I think with the 3.42 gears a lower stall torque converter would be nice, since I am always cruising around at like 1500rpm in OD.
:thumbsup: Lowering my final drive ratio from 4.10 is a future project. I've got a brand new 3.73 ring and pinion set sitting on the shelf. All I need to do now is find a Power Trax Lock Right unit for a reasonable price and I'll be ready to get after it. See, over a period of time, my goal is: balanced, highly efficient motor + improved fuel supply/filtering system + high quality, low stall torque converter = 20mpg on a 7,000# truck. That's what's behind the search for a dual stator lock-up TC. Incredible torque multiplication, max engine torque available sooner (to match the torque curve, and a strong lock up feature to eliminate any slippage and inefficiency in transmitting movement and motion. Considering how strong the 4L80 is, this is gonna be ideal for anything I might ever want to tackle: towing, hauling, cruising, whatever. :agreed:
 
Sounds like a great idea. Don't hear about it too often on these forums people changing their TC's out for diff stall speeds to achieve different power ranges and/or effeciencies.
 
Dave

Your goal of an efficient, 20 mpg truck, is what I would like to have also. I understand the balanced, highly efficient motor and improved fuel/filter system. But, i'm struggling with just what the low stall TC will do for fuel mileage. I know the lockup feature helps reduce slippage between the motor and tranny during cruise.

Can you "draw" me a picture of what the low stall TC will do for improved efficiency and economy? Is it because the lower stall speed would help TC lockup at lower RPM's?

I am definately looking for better mileage. I am currently seeing around 13 +/- mpg with winter blend fuel and saw my best of 15.5 mpg last summer. I have 4.10 gears and at this time don't want to change because of towing.

Don
 
When the converter is operating below its actual stall speed the two halves are "slipping" significantly, this creates heat in the transmission, quick. A lower stall speed converter gets through this phase of operation sooner in the rpm range and adds miles to the life of your transmission.

Matt, Synthetic fluid is always a good idea if you ask me, but it really makes sense here.:thumbsup:
 
I'm struggling with just what the low stall TC will do for fuel mileage. I know the lockup feature helps reduce slippage between the motor and tranny during cruise.
Here's the good and the bad. First the good: The TC is the wonderful piece of gear that give us automatic guys more 'at the trans' torque than the hand shaker folks ever dreamed of. We have the advantage of seeing our flywheel torque multiplied by over 150 percent. That means that the 385 pounds of torque that leaves the crankshaft translates into around 600 pounds of torque entering the trans. Very kewl. :agreed: But here's the bad: There's a price tag to this added torque - that multiplication only occurs when the two halves of the TC are rotating at different speeds. Specifically, the engine part (pump) is rotating faster than the trans input part (turbine). This slippage translates into heat and lost motion. In terms of overall mpg increases, the less slippage, the better. That's why the TC clutch was such a GREAT addition - it provided the torque multiplication we automatic guys love and the no-slip efficiency that the manual guys enjoy. Truly the best of both worlds. :thumbsup:

Can you "draw" me a picture of what the low stall TC will do for improved efficiency and economy? Is it because the lower stall speed would help TC lockup at lower RPM's?
The purpose of the stator (and stall speed) is to provide torque to the trans when the engine is least able to supply it. So the TC is designed to stop working as the engine enters its torque curve. For us diesel folks, that means a much lower rpm than the gassers need. By setting up a TC to reflect your actual needs - load carried/towed, engine tune, typical road speed, etc - you minimize the time the turbine and pump spend at maximum slippage. Minimizing this time provides two benefits: it allows your engine to work effectively in its comfort zone, and it provides a slight increase in fuel efficiency.

We're actually talking two concepts here: toque multiplication and fuel efficiency. the stator (and its designed stall speed) provide great torque multiplication and a little fuel efficiency. The TC clutch provides GREAT fuel efficiency, but no torque multiplication. Put these two together, and you have an incredibly effective combination! :D :D
 
Thats all good info. I will say I would like a lower stall TC because I sit at these low RPMs all the time inside the TC's stall range of like 1300-1600. When I am cruising like that any little change in load like cresting a very very slight hill and starting down usually causes it to lug a few times, like an oscilating lug, just a slight hunting for the right RPM. I can hear the engine quietly go wrow, wrow, wrow, wrow and then its good. Its not a concern to me, its very slight and only when cruising 40-50mph in that stall speed zone. But it does fine under larger loads, I can climb real hills at 1500rpm most of the time with 8psi of boost and it just hums a long, you could call that lugging in and of itself but it does it real strong and it just stays at the same RPM and speed just lowers boost and transitions smoothly after being loaded hard. It just handles very slight unloading strangely, probably because of the difference in transmision line pressure being much higher under high load.
 
Thanks Dave and Wrecker. The principles behind the TC are finally starting to sink in.

Does anybody know the what the stall speed of the stock TC is supposed to be? Also, Dave, what do you consider the optimum stall speed for an almost stock 6.5 such as mine? for economy? for towing? I have 4.10's, 265/75/16's, 3" downpipe and 4" back, snorkle removed. I would love to have an ATT and tunes for towing and economy, but I'm on a very limited budget so this may take a bit of time.

This TC info is so good I feel that it should broken out and made into a sticky.

Don
 
OK..........I'm still (a little) lost, say your tranny takes a dump and you need a rebuild.....What would you do as far as TC?

What would be the overkill version?
What would be the middle ground version?
What is the OEM version?

And how do you know your TC is bad/going bad?.......What are the signs to look for?

**These questions are designed to work with my learning curve, to add to all of the other info already given.**
 
When I am cruising like that any little change in load like cresting a very very slight hill and starting down usually causes it to lug a few times, like an oscillating lug, just a slight hunting for the right RPM. I can hear the engine quietly go wrow, wrow, wrow, wrow and then its good.
Ya know, that sounds a lot like 'chuggle'. That occurs when the TC clutch is engaging and disengaging because road speed and load are right on the edge of the lockup parameters. Normal condition, just aggravating.

Matt, Synthetic fluid is always a good idea if you ask me, but it really makes sense here.:thumbsup:
:thumbsup: :thumbsup: I'm converting to synthetic for the 'new' trans.

Does anybody know what the stall speed of the stock TC is supposed to be? Also, Dave, what do you consider the optimum stall speed for an almost stock 6.5 such as mine? for economy? for towing?
No real info on OEM stall. I've read and heard that it's in the 1300 - 1600 rpm range, but I can't find anything in my GM shop manuals that specifies. This morning, when I got to work, I pulled around back and did a quick stall test. Engine RPM climbed to 2100 and stayed there. So, that's the stall speed for my converter on my engine with my mods.
 
Back
Top