I always prefer the cable to electrical. On this site I hear of people in snow having issues, but here it was in high heat we had issues. Then of course simply wearing out for people that went off roading very frequently they wouldn’t last.
They had to get replaced under warranty- imo anything that wears out during warranty time frame tells me it is not built to last so manual connection isnthe way to go imo.
The one time in my life I was happy to have had electric shifting was when my wife was stuck in a snow storm and only exer drove in snow twice in her life before that, and one of those times I was with her and had to switch to me driving.
In our 2001 suburban we had -She called me and asked what to do- “See the button to the left of the steering wheel that says 4Hi… push it and tell me if the light comes on.” Yes. Ok now drive as if it is a really bad rainstorm.
If she had to pull cables, flip switches, or anything else she would have felt overwhelmed and waited until I came and got her. That was around 2002/3 iirc,
Once she was home watching the baby Inwas running all over the place with the Hummer draggin folks out. I was in Boulder City, she was in Vegas and there was only two paved roads then (2.5) that connects them. One is through the national park where Lake Mead is and they closed both- until I showed up at the park. I knew one of the Rangers and he let me go through if I promised not to take the road if it got risky, and call him if it had cleared up where the snow was bad.
I just did a few u-turns and kept smashing down the snow to where regular rigs could drive it easy enough. Then called him and went along my way to drop off the friend of ours who was baby sitting our kid in Vegas and go get my wife our kid- telling her to take that rarely used way is how to get home. That was also one of the four times I wished I had fixed the front heater core in the hummer - the rear heater is really tiny and the main heater core was bad when I bought it- still is. Thats on my “one of these days” lists. Can you guys imagine: a 6.5 rig that can’t put out good heat into the truck? Haha!
Sorry for the sidetrack- just the way my mind wanders…